Categories
Business News

A SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF A WAGE CASE

After near a four-year litigation, a wage case in the US District Court Northern District of Ohio was recently settled to our client’s satisfaction. T. Wang v. China Wok, et al. Case number 3:17-cv-00691 was filed on April 3, 2017. Our firm represented Plaintiff Ms. Wang. The original complaint was subsequently amended and supplemented. Additional parties were added as defendants. Ms. Lei Jiang was the lead counsel in this case.

The case was at the final stage – waiting for the trial when it was settled. All discovery was completed, and summary motions were filed and determined by the court. Due to COVID, the trial was delayed. Unexpected delay eventually facilitated the settlement. This proved to be advantageous for all parties involved because there will be no appeals.

Labor and employment disputes are one of our areas. If you have such issues, please contact us.

© 2021 Copyright by Lei Jiang LLC. All rights reserved.

Categories
Business News

2020 Business Valuation – A Recent U.S. Case

The U.S. Department of Labor recently prevailed in a district court of Virginia case involving multiple Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) valuation issues.

The case involved allegations that the selling shareholder, who was also a fiduciary of the employee stock ownership plan, as well as the bank hired to represent the ESOP as an independent fiduciary, breached their fiduciary duties by allowing the plan to overpay for the shareholder’s stock.

The district court issued a lengthy ruling on the case which addressed multiple common valuation practices such as normalization adjustments, discounting, capitalization rates, and proper look-back periods for the purposes of capitalization. For example, the Court found that:

  • The conclusion of value was strikingly close to an initial estimated value that had been floated by ESOP counsel and advisors at the inception of the transaction;
  • The appraisal was performed on a controlling basis even though the seller/owner and his wife were still going to be two of three ESOP co-trustees and occupy two of three company director seats;
  • Almost of all of the appraiser’s assumptions, including his capitalization rate, fluctuated significantly relative to previous appraisals that he had performed on the company and all in a direction towards a conclusion of higher value;
  • The appraiser did not obtain financial projections or prepare his own and get management buy-in and the appraisal utilized only a capitalized cash flow method to the exclusion of a discounted cash flow method(discounted cash flow method); and
  • The ESOP trustee raised many concerns with the draft appraisal but did not follow through and then went ahead and agreed to a purchase price before reviewing the final appraisal.

This case reminds us that (1) much discussions were needed to justify the departure from previous yearly valuations and big rise of stock value, (2) an impartial review of the valuation results might have red flagged the flaws, (3)  the fiduciaries would have been wise to remember that fiduciary duties imposed by ERISA are “the highest known to the law” and any decisions made in fiduciary capacity should have been made with an “eye single to the interests of the participants and beneficiaries.” (4) a genuine negotiation with respect to the purchase price should be conducted.

Lei Jiang Law Firm handles many aspects of business transactions. For questions, please contact us.

Categories
Business Litigation News

Civil Litigation – Important Changes to Ohio Rules of Civil Procedures

Recent amendments to the Ohio Rules of Civil Procedure will unify the timeline of court proceedings throughout the state.  For example, Ohio now has uniform motion deadlines to streamline processes.  The amendments became effective July 1, 2018 and serve to eliminate confusion regarding deadlines and other requirements.

Here are some of the specifics. For Motions for Summary Judgment, all responses are due 28 days after service of the motion, and replies are due 14 days after service of the response.

For all other motions, responses are due 14 days after service of the motion, and replies are due 7 days after service of the response.

Motions for purposes of trial, such as a motion in limine, must be filed at least twenty-eight days prior to the trial, while motions for purposes of a hearing must be served no later than fourteen days prior to the hearing.  Importantly, Rule 6 allows courts to modify the summary judgment and motion deadlines for good cause.

Discovery rules are also updated due to advancements in technology. Rule 33, 34, and 36 now state that the discovery must serve an electric copy on a shareable medium in an editable format.  These changes should result in a more streamlined and effective system. 

For legal issues, please contact us.

Categories
Business Litigation News

Civil Litigation in 2020

The Supreme Court of Ohio issued an order effectuating and expanding upon the emergency legislation Governor DeWine signed into law on March 27, 2020 in response to COVID-19, which tolled statutes of limitations, as well as litigation deadlines and timelines.  The Court’s order reflects the judicial branch’s reciprocation of H.B. 197 legislation and orders that all “time requirements” that are set to expire between March 9, 2020 and July 30, 2020 are tolled.  In effect, the order tolls all litigation deadlines that are due March 9 through July 30.

The order does allow for a court to supersede the tolling provision by issuing an order of its own on or after March 9, 2020.  Some courts, however, seem to be determined to press ahead due to concerns of unmanageable heavy case load down the road. Overall, the progress of civil cases is slowed in light of the pandemic.

Firmwide, we see no decrease of civil cases in 2020.  Five breach of contract cases alone came in before April 2020. Civil litigation is a big part of our practice. Our core substantive practice areas of corporate, business, real estate, international, and intellectual property often involve complex disputes that must be resolved in federal court. As a result, we have developed expertise capable of handling the most significant matters. 

In a civil litigation, we handle matters from pre-complaint investigation, through discovery, summary judgment, trial, and the appeals process. We are experienced yet small enough to ensure that client service remains at the forefront of every engagement. So, if you are burdened by business disputes, let us help you. For legal issues, please contact us.

Categories
Business News

2020 Mergers and Acquisitions

Our firm, Lei Jiang LLC, started 2020 with a good volume of deals and mergers and acquisitions. We continue to handle a variety of deals. In January, we successfully concluded an acquisition of a US college by a Canadian educational group. Then we put several deals together before COVID-19 spread in the US. They included a recycling company’s expansion and acquisition and several restaurant acquisitions. Currently, we are in the midst of a Chinese metal company’s second phase acquisition of a US company.

Even though the COVID-19 pandemic slowed down M&A activity due to uncertainty in valuations and companies focusing on liquidity and cost efficiencies, we expect to see more activities in three categories taking place:

  1. Well-funded strategic buyers using this opportunity to build sizeable positions in targets and /or attempt takeovers of undervalued companies;
  2. Corporates selling or spinning off non-core assets to address liquidity, leverage and valuation issues;
  3. Investors contributing capital in exchange for significant equity stakes in businesses in need of a recapitalization or with liquidity constraints.

If anything can be learned from the 2008-2009 financial crisis, we can expect a renewed use of equity as form of consideration for transactions among corporates. If you have any questions regarding M&A, please contact us. We specialize in international mergers and acquisitions and complex transactions.

For legal issues, please contact us.

Categories
Business News

Another Successful Case in Federal District Court

On January 23, 2017, an order was delivered in a case captioned as IIP Cleveland Regeneration, LLC, et al. v. Zhenfen Huang, et. al., Case No 1:16 CV 2673, pending in the U.S. District Court for Northern District of Ohio. Our firm represented the defendants in this case.  After vigorous defending, the District Court dismissed plaintiffs’ complaint. This resulted in a total and complete victory for our clients.

This case did not lasted long. After plaintiffs filed their complaint, we immediately responded with a motion to dismiss.  This was because the complaint was poorly written, without any factual substance and legal basis. Plaintiffs then amended their complaint, significantly altered the initial landscape of the complaint, even added an additional defendant in an effort to boost their case.  We quickly filed a second motion to dismiss.  In the end, legal fiction, no matter how voluminous it seemed, could not save plaintiffs’ ill-conceived complaint.  The district court agreed with us and dismissed this case.

Whether prosecuting or defending, we handle your case with the uttermost care and our best effort. If you or your company need a competent law firm to handle disputes or litigation, please contact us.

Categories
Business News

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) 2016 year-end review

Overall trend. The mergers and acquisitions Lei Jiang LLC handled in 2016 were mostly global in nature, involving Asia Pacific companies as buyers and American companies as sellers. The dominant buyers were again Chinese companies. But we saw different Chinese buyers, including Chinese private equity firms, publicly listed companies, and even private owned companies. The traditional outbound M&A was dominated by Chinese state-owned enterprises. The new trend signaled broader bases, bigger appetites, and increased capacity for Chinese companies to acquire U.S. companies.

Although this new array of buyers had a very short track record of cross-regional M&A, they have showed some experience and are comfortable in the deal. From our dealing with these customers, we have discerned factors behind this buying spree. They are 1) to boost the growth rate of the company, 2) lack of domestic targets for acquisitions, and 3) ease of the restrictions on finance.

Implications for U.S. companies. U.S. companies should consider Chinese companies as legitimate partners and buyers if they want to fully utilize the value. First, Chinese companies normally pay higher premium in acquiring U.S. companies. They take into consideration the long term development and potentials. Second, consistent with Chinese culture, Chinese buyers place high value on the relationship with the management before, during and after the transaction. Moreover, in the M&A we handled in 2016, all Chinese buyers retained the management team and gave generous compensations to the U.S. teams. Finally, according to Forbes, by the end of August 2016, China was so far the top acquirer of foreign companies. If the trend continued to the end of year, China would unseat the USA for the first time since 2006. Thus, U.S. companies simply cannot afford to ignore this group of acquirers.

Implications for Chinese/Asia Pacific companies. As mentioned, Chinese companies typically adopt a longer-time investment evaluation, causing them to pay a relatively higher premium. Moreover, paying premium to retain the target’s management team shows that Chinese companies are not familiar with the dynamics of the overseas market and are not capable of running the target initially. Still, cross-regional M&A can be a value enhancing strategy for Chinese companies. If it fits their long-term strategies, in the long run these companies will gain a competitive advantage in the global market.

Lei Jiang Law Firm has successfully concluded several M&A deals in 2016. Some are still in the process. We are proud to provide top-notch M&A services to our clients. Our team is skilled in cross-regional M&A. We understand the cultural difference, language nuance, and different regulatory requirements. We are here to make it happen.

Categories
Business

Thoughts on the U.S. Congressional Committee’s Proposal to Prohibit Chinese State-Owned Enterprises from Acquiring U.S. Assets

On November 16, 2016, the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC) recommended in its annual report to the U.S. Congress that bans Chinese state-owned enterprises from acquiring or gaining control of U.S. company, in order to prevent Chinese state-owned enterprises take advantages of acquired technologies for the benefits of China’s national interests at the expense of U.S. national security. Although the proposal has no legal power, it largely reflects the challenges faced by Chinese enterprises “going abroad”.

In fact, out of doubts about China’s rise, the United States’ agency responsible for reviewing foreign mergers and acquisitions of domestic companies in terms of national security and interests, the Council on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS), has always been concerned about Chinese companies, especially state-owned enterprises, acquiring important strategic assets or sensitive technologies in the United States. In 2007, Huawei and the US PE investment fund Bain Capital attempted to acquire the US information technology company 3Com. This case is worth examination for Chinese companies. In this case, the equity that Huawei intends to acquire can only reach 21.5% of 3Com’s equity at most, accounting for 3 seats in the 11-member board of directors. Huawei will not control 3Com, nor will it obtain sensitive US technology. In addition, Huawei is a private enterprise. Still, Huawei President Ren Zhengfei’s military background has been questioned, and the U.S. market is skeptical about the deal’s success, as 3Com’s cybersecurity business includes customers in the U.S. Department of Defense. Huawei and Bain Capital ultimately withdrew their acquisition applications due to expectations that they would not be able to obtain CFIUS approval. In addition to Huawei, cases in which the applicant withdrew the acquisition application or the acquisition application was rejected include the acquisition of four small wind farms in Oregon by a subsidiary of China Sanyi Group in the United States in 2012 and the acquisition of the US oil company Unocal by China National Offshore Oil Corporation in 2005.

When Chinese companies plan to acquire US corporate assets, they should take into account that CFIUS approval may be a decisive factor in the success of the acquisition. First, although U.S. law does not mandate that M&A transactions need to submit an application to CFIUS, CFIUS has the right to require the cancellation of the transaction after the transaction is completed. Therefore, it is necessary to assess whether the M&A may have U.S. national security issues before the transaction, or consider voluntarily submitting an application to CFIUS. Submitting an application is one way. Second, in the process of dealing with CFIUS, we can learn from the experience of the Huawei case. Bain Capital, as the joint acquirer of Huawei, came forward to negotiate with CFIUS. Its pure American background can play a certain role in reducing the resistance of the United States to the acquisition. Although the final result failed to meet expectations, it is still an ingenious work worth learning from. Also, possible changes in the market during the CFIUS approval period should not be ignored. After the applicant submits the complete application materials, the CFIUS initial review time is 30 days, but if the foreign acquirer is a foreign state-owned enterprise or is controlled by a foreign government, CFIUS must initiate a 45-day in-depth investigation procedure, and the entire approval process may take up to 90 days. Finally, while state-backed Chinese companies encounter hostility in overseas markets, there may be opportunities for truly private companies. The British “Financial Times” reported that governments of various countries, including the United States, are tending to treat different Chinese companies differently, and small-scale investments from Chinese private companies are often warmly welcomed.

Categories
Business News Real Estate

A Successful Trial in U.S. District Court for Northern District of Ohio

One more successful trial was conducted by attorneys in Lei Jiang Law Firm. Attorney Jiang was the lead counsel. He, et al. v. Rom, et al., Case No. 1:15-CV-01869, was initially filed as a class action in the U.S. District Court for Northern District of Ohio. Three Plaintiffs represented a class of 140 people against eight individual and corporate defendants.  Class action, international parties, service issues, taking evidence under Hague Convention, and electronic discovery all render this case one of the most complex cases.  But we see it as an opportunity to establish ourselves in the global litigation and advanced dispute resolution arena.

Electronic discovery presented a unique challenge in this case.  Our firm represented Plaintiffs and were dumped with 86 gigabyte (GB) of electronic stored information (ESI) after a successful motion to compel filed by us.  The dumping was just one month before the discovery cut off deadline. Considering that 1GB typically contains 64,782 pages of documents (more pages for email files).  86 GB contains an enormous amount of documents for review. Yet, we swiftly employed a comprehensive strategy, utilized latest software and platform, and conducted document review in the most effective and efficient manner.  Our team, attorneys and computer forensic expert, worked diligently on the data.   As a result, the relevant information was quickly extracted for litigation. We were able to review a large amount of information within a relatively short period of time.

Although Plaintiffs’ effort in class certification failed, the final result was a success. The case proceeded to trial. The four day trial resulted a complete victory for our clients.  Plaintiffs prevailed on all claims submitted to the jury, including fraud and violation of Ohio Deceptive Trade Practice Action.  Plaintiffs also successfully pierced corporate veils of all remaining corporate defendants – making their owner(s) personally liable for the corporate misconduct. Finally, Plaintiffs were awarded with punitive damage and attorney fee.  This was a stunning victory for Plaintiffs, considering fraud, piercing the corporate veil, and seeking punitive damage were the most difficult tasks in any lawsuit.

In this case, we also utilized new technology for virtual remote deposition and contemporaneous transmission of trial testimony from the other side of the globe – Hong Kong.  The new technology we used was tested for the first time in the Northern District of Ohio.  It significantly reduced the cost, and eased restrictions on time, place, facility and equipment.  In this case, legal expertise and technology worked together seamlessly.

It must be mentioned that Plaintiffs were fortunate to have the case be heard in the court of honorable Judge James Gwin. Judge Gwin took no shortcuts, made no detours, and in this case, he made the complete journey necessary to accomplish justice.

If you or your company need a competent law firm to handle international disputes or litigation, please contact us.

Categories
Business News Real Estate

Media Report of Zheng, et al. v. SouFun, et al.

On August 23, 2015, Ms. Zheng and several others, as representatives of a class, filed a class action at U.S. District Court Northern District of Ohio against the biggest online real estate investment portal in China SouFun Holding Ltd. and SouFun International Ltd.

The complaint alleged fraud, violation of Ohio Deceptive Trade Practice Act, violation of Ohio Consumer Sales Practice Law, violation of Ohio real estate law, unjust enrichment, and breach of fiduciary duty. Lei Jiang Law Firm represents Plaintiffs and the class.

Since this was a case involving international parties, the service was a challenge because it must go through Hague Convention service of process. Plaintiffs successfully perfected the service through Hague Convention.

Major Chinese media in China and the U.S. and have reported on this case. The case is being closely watched by many due to the ever increasing trend of Chinese investing in the U.S. and global real estate.

For a report from the People’s Daily, the official media, click here.
Reports from the biggest Chinese media (in Chinese) QQ, Sina, SOHU, NETEASE.
Reports from the biggest U.S. Chinese media (in Chinese) USChinaPress, 中金在线.

Call Now Button